Easy Cacao Nibs Recipes and Cocoa Benefits

This post may contain affiliate links and I earn a small commission from qualifying purchases. For more information please read my disclosure policy.

cacao bean and cacao nibs recipes

Looking for a delight while you’re at home or plan to go on a picnic? Well, you’re lucky today ;-). Below you will find easy cacao nibs recipes you can make at home, which will make you happy(literally) are also quite healthy, perfectly keto and gluten free too.

Widely used in cooking and to make high-quality dark chocolate, cocoa beans always delight our taste buds and make us happy.

Scientific name: Theobroma cacao

Other names: Raw Cocoa, Cocoa seeds, cacao nibs. Cocoa tree  is also closely related to the cupuaçu fruit which is from the same family..

What is the cocoa bean?

 

Cocoa beans, or raw cacao(cacao usually refers to a high quality more natural organic version of cocoa produced in small farms in limited quantities also known as ceremonial cacao), are the seeds of the cacao tree fruit of the Theobroma family, it’s well known for being used in the manufacture of chocolate. They are found in the center of the cocoa fruit, which contains from 16 to 60 seeds, placed on 5 rows similar to a box of eggs.

Cultivated in many countries with a warm and humid climate, the cocoa tree yields about a hundred fruits per year, which themselves contain about forty beans, wrapped in a white pulp. Once extracted, they are fermented and then dried to remove the pulp, attenuate the acidity and develop the aromas.

 

cacao tree fruit Theobroma

Fresh cocoa beans are quite sticky, because they are covered with a white pulp, sweet-tart mucilage consisting of 80% water, 15% glucose and 5% pectin.

Once harvested, the husks are broken by hand, the seeds are sorted and cleaned, then fermented for 5-6 days, which has the effect of increasing tenfold the active nutrients and enzymes, as well as reducing bitterness. They are then dried slowly in the sun for 1 to 4 weeks.

Since raw cocoa beans are not roasted, they retain their chocolatey and rather bitter flavor, a powerful but refined aroma, as well as all their nutritional and therapeutic properties.

How do they make chocolate bars from cocoa beans?

 

chocolate bars from cocoa beans process

They undergo 2 other transformations for the manufacture of cocoa powder and chocolate bars: roasting and grinding. To roast them, they are heated at 150°C for about 25 min, which develops all the wonderfull aromas of cocoa. The beans are then ground to form a thick liquid cocoa paste from which the fat (Cocoa Butter) is extracted.

The dark chocolate we know and love today consists of a mixture of cocoa paste, cocoa butter and sugar. The proportions vary depending on the desired chocolate: dark chocolate 99%, 90%, 80%, 70% etc. the percentage indicates the amount of cocoa paste.

Other ingredients are also added to make different types of chocolate: milk, spices, Madagascar bourbon vanilla, oils, hazelnuts, almonds, fruits, etc.

During this stage, the fat is removed from the beans, it is called Cocoa Butter, which is mostly used in the food and pharmaceutical cosmetic industry.

Then the roasted cocoa beans are ground to a powder, kept as is or chopped(crushed) to pieces and will give us the so called Cacaonibs .

Focus on cleaning cocoa beans

Some producers remove completely the white pulp that covers the beans, others do not. This in no way changes the quality of the product, but it results in some difference:

– the carefully cleaned cocoa beans are purplish red, their taste is slightly sweeter

– the others that are not cleaned from the pulp are almond brown. Their taste is more raw, slightly bitter.

Focus on drying cocoa beans

If the seeds are dried for too long, they develop a purple or black color. If they are not dried enough, they are clear, but don’t last long and become rancid fairly quickly and get mold.

dry cocoa beans
cocoa beans dried for too long

 

There are 10 types of cocoa beans:

  • Criollo Cacao beans (available here),
  • Amelonado,
  • Nacional,
  • Contamana,
  • Curaray,
  • Cacao guiana,
  • Iquitos,
  • Maranon,
  • Nanay
  • Purus.

And here is a short history of cacao:

According to Aztec mythology, it was the God of vegetation and its folower Quetzalcóatl, who taught men how to grow cocoa tree, as a gift of his mercy.

The term cocoa comes from the Nahuatl cacahuatl or guachahua, itself derived from the maya kakaw, which refers to the cocoa beans. The name of the tree ” Theobroma cacao ” means in Greek:”food of the Gods”.

cocoa fruit

The use of cocoa beans is traced back to antiquity in Central and South America, among the Aztecs, the Olmecs and the Maya. Archaeologists have found traces of Mokaya ceramics from Paso de la Amada, on the Pacific coast of Chiapas, and pre-Olmec ceramics from El Manatí, on the coast of the Gulf of Mexico, dated between 1900 and 1750 BC.

Cocoa beans were used as a bargaining medium, for paying taxes and buying slaves from 1,000 years BC. This use continued up until recently, for example, it is known that 1,200 cocoa beans were worth a Mexican peso in 1550, in the Aztecs empire a turkey costs 100 cocoa beans and an avocado is worth 3 beans.

It was also used as an offering to the deities and the dead, as a dowry for marriages, etc. It was the Aztecs who spread the seed in Central America.

From Western history (I say this, because we know today that it was not Christopher Columbus who first discovered America, but the Vikings 6 centuries earlier), the Aztecs showed the famous dried cocoa seed to Christopher Columbus during the discovery of the Caribbean in 1492.

However, Christopher Columbus had no interest in cocoa beans at this time, and it was the conquistadors, Fernand Cortez, who decided to bring this fruit back to Spain when they returned from the conquest of the new world.

Indeed, the Aztec emperor Montezuma, made Fernand Cortez taste a drink reserved for Kings and Gods only: The Xocolatl, the ancestor of chocolate ! This royal cocoa drink was made by grinding roasted cocoa beans and diluted in water. It was then added vanilla aromas and other spices such as chili or husky seeds to give it a red color.

cocoa raw chocolate bar

The warm and bitter drink did not immediately become famous among the colonial elite, until the Spaniards added to the drink an ingredient that changed everything: sugar!

Fernand Cortez brought the bean and the recipe for cocoa with him and introduced it to the King of Spain Charles V in 1528. It is a success, the King adores and the xocolatl knows a craze throughout the Spanish court.

From Spain, cocoa invades all of Europe except for one country: France. Indeed, Louis XIV did not like cocoa, and out of the question to go against the tastes of the Sun King ! It will be necessary to wait until the beginning of the 20th century for it to really reappear.

Until the 20th century, cocoa was reserved for the bourgeoisie because it was very expensive. It is consumed as a drink, but also as confectionery.

Anecdotally, the church was very wary of chocolate drink, forbidden or at least not recommended in their religion, because known to be a powerful aphrodisiac.

Today, cocoa is grown all over the planet: central and South America of course, but also West Africa and Southeast Asia. 95% of the world’s cocoa production comes from family farming and small producers.

Among the species of cocoa tree, the best is Criollo, which accounts for about 5% of world production. Except that to have the Criollo appellation, the tree must grow in Peru. If the same species grows elsewhere, as is the case with ours that grows in Cameroon, its beans are called “Native” beans.

Cocoa is perfect for spicing up a dressing.

It can be an original ingredient to make your spreads, you can add it in your guacamole, Ktipiti, Muhammara, tzatziki, eggplant caviar, hummus, beet puree, tuna or sardine rillettes, broken pea spread, etc.

You can use it crushed to flavor all your sauces, gravy dishes and simmered dishes.

Its flavor goes well with potatoes, pasta, candied tomatoes, beans, almond fish, or some seafood. Just crush them and add them at the end of cooking.

It’s excellent in drinks, you can use it to give flavor to your smoothies, milkshakes, hot chocolate, etc.

Also Read:  Shrimp Scampi Pasta Recipe

What are the health benefits of cocoa beans?

 

All the properties discussed in this paragraph are equivalent to a consumption of 10 cocoa beans. Its virtues are optimal when they are raw as sold here, and not when they are roasted.

Cocoa beans are very nutritious and invigorating. They contain a lot of natural healthy fats (50 %), fibers (15 %), proteins (12 %), and above all a remarkable content of polyphenols, with strong antioxidant properties. These strengthen the vessels, promote circulation and protect cells from aging. Cocoa is also rich in magnesium (anti-stress), theobromine (stimulant) and anandamide (molecule of well-being and love). All of these special nutrients will work together to bring you the wonderful chocolate feel on your palate and will also make happy by incteasing and stimulating the release of dopamine and serotonin in your brain. That’s why we love chocolate so much.

On the other hand, we have less of the fun and euphoric side that chocolate provides, because there is no sugar.

Cocoa is a bean seed that contains more than 300 nutrients and active natural substances. Note its remarkable magnesium content, it is among the best dietary sources of magnesium: 500 mg magnesium per 100 g of beans.

In addition, it is an excellent source of calcium, potassium and phosphorus.

All this has many beneficial effects: balances the nervous system, fights stress, anxiety, fatigue, nervous and muscle tension. It improves sleep, concentration and mood.

In addition, the beans contain anandamide, a substance that creates a feeling of euphoria, which is also called the molecule of happiness. They increase the level of serotonin, the brain component of good mood.

Raw cocoa bean is an incredible source of antioxidants, from the family of flavonoids and polyphenols (epicatechin), equivalent to more than 10% of the weight of the seed ! This is still much more than sencha green tea or even Goji berries.

These antioxidants improve the defenses against free radicals that attack and destroy cells, and allow the prevention of many diseases: high cholesterol, cardiovascular diseases, diabetes, cancers, degeneration of neurons, arteriosclerosis, eye and vision diseases, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, etc.

It is an excellent aphrodisiac that improves libido, thanks to phenethylamine which has the effect of releasing endorphins, compounds released during sexual intercourse. In South America, it is often associated with maca Lepidium peruvianum and Muira Puama wood for greater effect.

The cocoa seed, by its content of ferulic acid, has a role in the breakdown of lipids to release energy, which promotes weight loss. It would also have a satiating effect.

The theobromine contained in it has antitussive, diuretic, vasodilating and especially stimulating properties. Its tonic effect is slightly amplified by the presence of a small amount of caffeine. It is therefore the ideal food for breakfast, in addition to being a good source of energy. Its physical, intellectual stimulating effect, and its action on mood have long been recognized.

Raw cocoa would be, like organic baobab powder, a natural aspirin. The Department of nutrition at the University of California, Davis discovered that cocoa thins the blood and prevents the formation of blood clots. This discovery showed that eating raw cocoa is just as beneficial as taking an aspirin.

Raw cocoa is also recommended in pregnant women, because it is rich in vitamin B9, folic acid, vitamins A, B1, C, D and E, trace elements and minerals. This has the effect of preventing certain diseases and malformations such as spina bifida or autism.

As they are rich in fiber, cocoa beans allow an easier intestinal bowel movement.

It is also an ingredient rich in sulfur and zinc, perfect for the reconstruction of collagen, keratin, and therefore on the shine and strength of hair, skin and nails.

Incidentally, sulfur and zinc are beneficial for the liver and pancreas, for cell health, blood sugar regulation, and for the immune system.

Ingredients to making chocolate bean cocoa shell

Rich in iron, the cocoa bean is ideal in case of anemia: 10g is enough to bring us our daily intake of iron.

let me quote the great German naturalist, geographer and explorer Alexander von Humboldt : “cocoa bean is a phenomenon that nature has never repeated; We have never found so many qualities combined in such a small fruit.”

Nutritional values per 100 g :

– Calories: 520 Cal (2140 kJ)

– Fat (cocoa butter): 43 g

– Protein : 20 g

– Dietary fibre: 8.4 g

– Starch: 7 g

– Water : 5 g

– Mineral Substances: 6 g

– Cellulose: 4 g

– Theobromine: 2 g

– Carbohydrates: 1,3 g

Next we will look at few cocoa nibs and beans recipes you can prepare easily.

Although they are made to be eaten directly, either as a snack or as an aperitif, you can also cook your cocoa beans! We offer recipes with cocoa beans, from the easiest to the most original, to cook the best this dried fruit. let yourself be guided, embark on board the Spice Island for a tour of the world of flavors !

 

Easy cacao nibs recipes you can make at home

 

cacao nibs recipe

10 easy Recipe ideas based on cocoa nibs/beans

Try any of these easy cacao nibs recipes which you can make at home and you won’t regret it.

Cocoa bean give a special flavor to your dishes by bringing a sweet side and bitterness at the same time. It is possible to integrate the cocoa bean in a refined cuisines or in a homemade recipe which very easy to make. Here are some recipes with cocoa bean.

So, how to use cocoa beans in cooking? Most times you’ll need to crush or grind them before using them in your recipes.

 

1. Crispy hazelnut tuile with cacao nibs recipe

 

hazelnut tuile cookie biscuit with cacao nibs recipes

Ingredients

1 egg white, 30 g. sugar, 15 gr. flour, 15 gr. butter, 15 gr hazelnut powder, 4 to 5 cocoa beans.

Method

Crush the cocoa beans in a pestle. Mix egg white, butter, flour and cocoa beans.

Then spread the dough on a baking sheet. Bake 4 minutes at 180°. Repeat until the dough runs out.

 

2. Shortbread Cookies with butter and cacao nibs recipe

shortbread cookies cacao nibs recipe

Ingredients

320 g. of flour, 25 g. of almond powder, ¼ g. of salt, 1g. of yeast, 250 ml of milk, 70 grams of coconut powder, 70 g. of cocoa beans. Mix the flour, almond powder, salt and yeast.

Method

Add the liquids and add the cocoa beans. Stir well. Lay out a small pile on a baking sheet. Cook for 20 minutes at 350 degrees F | 175 degrees C (thermostat 6).

 

3. Confit of Duck legs, small beans and cocoa bean cassoulet sauce

Confit of Duck legs, small beans and cocoa bean cassoulet sauce

Ingredients
4 farmer duck thighs, 400 gr of pre-cooked small beans, 200 ml of sour cream, 6 to 7 cocoa beans, 1 tsp cinnamon coffee, 1 tsp coriander.

Method

Put the duck legs directly to return to a frying pan without fat. When the thighs are well browned, discard the excess fat. Then add the sour cream. Add the coriander and cinnamon and salt and pepper to taste. Stir in the cocoa beans, dilute with broth and simmer for 50 minutes. Add the small beans 15 minutes before the end of cooking. Serve duck legs with cocoa sauce.

4. A Tea  infusion of Cacao Nibs recipe

cacao nibs tea recipe shell
Hot Cacao Tea. Fresh hot chocolate herbal tea made of cacao bean flakes, which is rich in flavonoids and antioxidants

 

You can use cocoa beans in recipes for hot tea infusions. It’s best to use dried cocoa beans. Thus, the skin/shells of the cocoa beans is used to infuse them in hot water.

5. Cacao nibs Spreading paste recipe

Cacao nibs Spreading paste recipe

The whole cocoa bean soaked and softened in hot water can be used to be mixed with hazelnut butter and prunes to make a wonderful cacao spread paste.

The uses of cocoa beans are numerous and it is possible to make sauces which youcan add to meats or other sweet and salty dishes. Cocoa beans are excellent for integrating into pastries too.

 

6. Truffles with cacao nibs recipe

truffer with cacao nibs recipe

prep:20 min
time: 4 min
difficulty:easy

Ingredients
Number of portions:4
For 12 to 15 truffles :

  • 12 to 15 whole raw cocoa beans
  • 15 ml Cocoa Butter or coconut oil
  • 30 ml of agave nectar or maple syrup
  • 45 gr. raw cocoa powder + a little more to cover the truffles

Preparation

  1. Prepare the ganache by melting cocoa butter or coconut oil in a water bath over very soft heat.
  2. Add the agave nectar and 45 ml of cocoa powder and mix well.
  3. Once homogeneous, put in the fridge for about an hour, while the ganache is frozen.
  4. To shape the truffles, take a small spoonful of ganache and bury the cocoa bean in it.
  5. The Bean should be well covered with ganache.
  6. Roll the truffle into the cocoa powder.

It is better to keep these truffles in the fridge until they are served.

 

7. Cocoa liquor from cacao nibs recipe

Cocoa liquor from cacao nibs recipe
Creamy sweet liqueur with chocolate and ice, selective focus

 

This recipe is similar to my homemade baileys recipe so check it out.

2 cups
10 min
10 min
easy

Ingredients

  • 200 ml of water
  • 150 g brown sugar
  • 3 tonka beans
  • 3 vanilla pods
  • 750 ml of alcohol
  • 150 g bitter cocoa

Preparation

Make a syrup with water and sugar. For this let boil 10 minutes.
Off the fire add vanilla pods, pounded tonka beans.Let cool.
Then mix the cocoa intimately with alcohol; add this mix to the fragrant syrup. Mix well.
Strain and bottle, leaving the vanilla pods.

Also Read:  Caramelized Onion Dip Recipe - Homemade & Easy

 

8. Granola with coconut and cacao nibs recipe

Granola with coconut and cacao nibs recipe

(This was my first attempt for using the cacao nibs in a recipe when I first bought them and since then I’ve been using them quite regularly in all sorts of creative ways to enjoy them. For examples look up the recipes above.)

A while ago, I found myself nose to nose, in the shelves of a health store, with cocoa beans. It had a good aroma of almonds and would taste chocolatey, with lots of nutritional claims on it, good for my brain I guess. So I put them in my basket, and wisely waited for the snack time to taste them. I felt a slight disappointment when I chew them up first: it is pure raw cocoa, with all the bitterness that goes with it, and then what?

Cacao nibs are nothing special at first: when you chew, they crunches in your teeth. They are hard(so be careful not to crush your teeth). Not delighted really, but I’m not giving up yet either- I knew well that I would find a way to cast a spell (cook) on them, sooner or later.

And Bingo: while searching on the net, I came across a recipe that would allow me to pass on both my crunchy cocoa beans and my bag of coconut chips that had not yet been finished since time. The problem is that, as with all good recipes, it dramatically makes you want to buy back the ingredient you previously wanted to get rid of. Because granola is very, very addictive like this homemade granola or this paleo granola bars version (for me at least)– you have been warned!

 

For 1 small jar

5 from 1 reviews
Easy cacao nibs recipes and cocoa benefits
 
Ingredients
  • 1 mug of small oat flakes (or other cereal flakes)
  • ¼ cup cocoa beans
  • ¼ cup of almonds or pistachios
  • ¼ cup coconut shavings
  • 1 teaspoon cinnamon powder
  • ½ tsp salt
  • 2 tbsp agave syrup
  • 1 tbsp bulging almond puree
Instructions
  1. Preheat oven to 180 °C. in a salad bowl, mix oat flakes, cocoa beans and slightly crushed almonds, dried coconut shavings, cinnamon and salt.
  2. In a saucepan, heat the agave syrup with the almond puree, while mixing, until the whole thing is liquid.
  3. Add the contents of the salad bowl and mix with a spoon until the whole mixture is well impregnated.
  4. Spread on a baking sheet. Bake for 15 minutes. The mixture should be well browned – if it is not, leave it in the oven 5 more minutes.
  5. Take the plate out of the oven and allow to cool. Crush and place in a jar.
 

Granola can be stored for 1 month in an airtight jar (it lasted 3 days).

 

9. Fluffy cookies with cocoa nibs recipe aka Cookies for the grown-ups!

cookies with cocoa nibs recipe

Ingredients
For fifteen cookies

  • 220 g flour
  • 80 g white sugar
  • 80 g brown sugar
  • 120 g soft butter
  • 1 egg
  • 1 cup baking powder
  • 1 cup of Bourbon vanilla powder from Madagascar or in pods
  • 1/4 cup salt
  • 80 g of chocolate chips
  • 1 cups roasted cocoa beans

 

4 portions.

Difficulty:Easy

cook time: 20 min

Preparation – 10 min

First, preheat your oven to 180 °C.
Mix the butter with the two sugars. Then add the egg and vanilla pod powder. Mix well.
Then add the dry ingredients, flour, yeast and salt. Mix until a homogeneous device is obtained, which easily peels off the bowl.
Finally add the chocolate chips as well as the beans that you will have burst to the size that suits you. Opt for fairly small pieces, to avoid saturating with bitterness at the tasting.
Form balls using a tablespoon and place them on a baking sheet with baking paper. Lightly flatten the cookies before baking.
Cooking takes about 10 minutes. The cookie must have an edge that cracks gently but the heart always fluffy.
Have a nice meal!

Note:

Did you know it was possible to eat this raw cookie dough? Yes! But for this you just need to remove the yeast and Brown the flour 5 minutes in a very hot oven, to destroy the bacteria !

 

10. Cookies with milk and cacao nibs recipe

Cookies with milk and cacao nibs recipe

Biscuits with milk and cocoa beans

8 persons
Preparation time 30 min.
Cooking time15 min.

Ingredients

. 150 g of semi-complete wheat flour . 50 g of chestnut flour . 20 g of beer yeast in sequins . 80 g butter, 100 ml of milk . 80 g of brown sugar . 2 tablespoon (s) of roasted cocoa beans

Preparation

1.Mix wheat flour, chestnut flour, beer yeast in glitter and 1 pinch of salt.

2.Warm milk and butter, add sugar. Stir until dissolved.
3.Pour into the flours, mix quickly and form a ball. Cover with stretch film and let stand for at least 1 h in a cool place.
4.Chop the cocoa beans with a large kitchen knife.
5.Preheat the oven on th. 6/180°. Roll out the dough thinly enough on the floured worktop. Cut out the Cookies in the form of small-butter.
6.Store them on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper. Sprinkle them with chopped cocoa beans.
7.Bake 12 to 15 minutes in the oven. Let the cookies cool for 15 minutes on a grate.

 

Tip: For kids! Use chopped chocolate and add a few shards of cocoa beans (in small quantities) so that they discover the slightly bitter and powerful cocoa flavor, and the crunchy texture.

 

To make chocolate, the beans are roasted to enhance even more their flavors. But those found in organic stores are often “raw”: their benefits are thus preserved.

 

How to properly choose cocoa beans and cacao nibs?

Raw cocoa beans have the advantage of better preserving antioxidants, while those that have been roasted have a more pronounced cocoa flavor. “Each source offers specific flavors. It is interesting to taste two different ones and compare them. Are there more popular varieties than others? Criollo is the rarest and most refined. But the variety does not do everything. Still it is necessary that the fermentation and drying have been well conducted to give a quality product.

How to consume cocoa beans?

 

Their raw flavor, not at all sweet and slightly bitter, can surprise. They are perfect to replace chocolate with coffee, or as snacks. When crushed, cocoa beans and cacao nibs can be used in recipes as a spice that goes together with both salty and sweet. It can be sprinkled like large salt on a foie gras, game or even fish. On the dessert side, they add crispness to a chocolate mousse, a banana cake, small madeleines…

Note: it is better to avoid consuming them in the evening, because of their stimulating effect and caffeine content.

 

What science says about cocoa benefits?

 

Studies conducted on cocoa show that this “good mood” food is composed of many molecules with psychoactive properties. This would explain our drive towards chocolate, especially during moments of anxiety, stress or fatigue.

As the end of the Year celebrations approach, the shop windows of the chocolatiers are full of temptations and you have a hard time resisting… You are not the only one since 9 out of 10 French people admit to being addicted to chocolate. But, rest assured, even if your taste for chocolate resembles an addiction, according to expert nutritionists, one can not really talk about addiction, but more simply about “chocolatomania”!

For scientists, what seems to explain our drive to chocolate in the event of a soft stroke or depression is that chocolate is composed of 500 different molecules, some of which have psychoactive properties : theobromine, caffeine, phenylethylamine, magnesium, serotonin… An experiment conducted in the animal illustrates this drive towards chocolate. Intravenous injection in dogs of phenylethylamine, one of the components of cocoa, stimulates its impulse for this molecule whose structure is close to those of amphetamines!

We stock up on serotonin, the hormone of nice mood and happiness

Another neuromediator, serotonin, present in cocoa has antidepressant effects. This same serotonin could also promote the reduction of appetite, hence the interest of maintaining chocolate in reasonable quantities in slimming diets. A study by the University of San Diego supports the idea that dark chocolate is good for the line, indicating that the slimming effect of chocolate would be related to the content of catechins, antioxidants that would promote weight loss and fineness of muscles.

Finally, let’s not forget the taste pleasure that the consumption of chocolate provides, linked to the subtle tastes of different cocoa beans.

Prefer dark chocolate

Dark chocolate contains a less sugar than milk chocolate. It is rich in copper since 100 g of chocolate makes it possible to cover 22% of the recommended daily intakes. It is also rich in magnesium (112 mg per tablet) and iron. Milk chocolate, on the other hand, is much richer in calcium and phosphorus. White chocolate is also rich in calcium, but significantly sweeter and belongs to confectionery.

By knowing more for the food you consume you ensure proper and optimal health for you and your family. I hope you enjoyed this lengthy post and the cacao nibs recipes listed above.

If you have any questions or comment let me know in the section below.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *